5/1/2000 | 6 MINUTE READ

TransAtlantic Transitions: Plastics Move From Over There To Over Here

Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Although the U.S. is certainly a place where plenty of trends are started, some engineering trends start in Europe and make their way west. As in the case of some plastic applications under the hood.


Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Related Suppliers

“Over There” is how western Europe was described in a World War One-era music hall tune. Although the world is arguably a smaller place today, it still seems as though Over There is a place where things are done somewhat differently—at least initially—than they are done Over Here.

Take the utilization of plastic for intake manifolds, for example.

According to John M. Ferrighetto, Business Manager-Americas, DuPont Automotive (Troy, MI), “Polymeric air intake manifolds began in Europe in the mid to late ‘70s.” Over Here, they didn’t start showing up in sizeable quantities until the early 1990s. Ferrighetto says that DuPont data show that right now, about 65% of the air intake manifolds on passenger vehicles are made with plastic, nylon 66 primarily, with some nylon 6. “By 2004, our data suggests we’ll have a relatively penetrated market here in the U.S.” He’s talking about as many as 95% of the intake manifolds being produced with plastic. As for the remaining, he believes that there will be exceptions such as applications where there are extreme heat requirements or small volumes that don’t necessarily justify doing retooling from metal to plastic.

Where there is something of a transition occurring, Ferrighetto points out, is in the area of the type of nylon used to produce the manifolds. That is, he says that in 1998, 100% of the air intake manifolds produced in the Americas were made with nylon 66. This is the material that started it all. So the equipment necessary to make manifolds with this material—mainly lost-core molding—is in place. There is installed capacity. But in the not-too-distant future, as there are manifold redesigns, there is, that data describe, a change to nylon 6 which, Ferrighetto explains, provides an overall cost advantage in that there is a lower capital equipment cost (the approach here is to make separate parts that are joined through vibration welding), a reduced cycle time, and a slightly lower material cost. The numbers indicate that by 2004, there may be a 60/40 split between 66 and 6.

Asked why he thinks that nylon 66 was the preferred material at the start, he points out that when there was a switch from metal to plastic, “there was a big perceived risk.” So the properties of nylon 66 provided the level of comfort that was required to ameliorate that risk. But now, there is a better understanding of what the conditions under which the material must perform (lower temperatures, no EGR issues, no chemical exposure), so nylon 6 can fit the bill. Looking out 10 years, Ferrighetto thinks that nylon 6 may account for 70% of the manifolds.

Is Aluminum All Done?

No. But the figures for moving to nylon are pretty compelling: there is a weight savings of as much as 40 to 60% and a minimum cost savings of 25%. “The financial advantage of using nylon is just too great to stem the tide of commercialization.”

However, Ferrighetto acknowledges that there are always going to be special applications that are suited for aluminum (or magnesium). He points out that when it comes to low volume applications, aluminum can be more economical than plastic because of lower tooling cost. (Which is somewhat interesting inasmuch as when it comes to, say, outer body panels on a vehicle, the argument is made that the tooling costs for plastic are less than those for metal {i.e., steel, in most cases} when it comes to low-volume applications.)

The Next Generation.

So there’s a plastic intake manifold molded by a variety of suppliers. It’s then shipped to an OEM. The OEM adds a variety of components: fuel rail, throttle body, air cleaner box, sensors . . . And installs the whole thing on the car.

But what about providing a module? Which is what some Tier One suppliers are now doing. The OEM no longer has to install an assortment of peripherals, just assembles the single package on the car.

Tomorrow, however, it may go even further. “Our vision is that there is an integrated air-fuel module that combines as many features as possible in a single molding,” Ferrighetto says. So there may be a manifold with the rocker covers hanging off the side, air cleaner box, throttle body. . . Although the practice would be—assuming that these various components are made of plastic—to vibration weld each of them together, Ferrighetto explains that what they have in mind is the use of “shared wall” technology.

What he means by this is that instead of producing, say, both a manifold and air cleaner box then welding the two together, wall-to-wall, the combined manifold/air cleaner box would be designed so that there is a single wall with a functional component on either side of that wall. Advantages of this include weight savings, material cost reduction, and improved under-the-hood packaging.

Think About It.

Mark E. Schuchardt, Technical Specialist, DuPont Engineering Polymers-Automotive, injects, “The key is not just putting everything together, but doing it intelligently.” Schuchardt spends much of his time checking out what other industries are doing with plastics and then determining whether there is applicability in automotive: “I take what is practically doable now in other industries and put them together” (e.g., he points out that some automakers are switching to plastic dipsticks: even though making them out of metal is less expensive, the automakers realize that there is a consumer friendliness associated with having clearly identified service points under the hood, so they are using color stable polymers for these applications—materials that were developed to produce handles for oven ranges).

Schuchardt thinks that the move to plastic for some under-the-hood components should drive a rethinking of the way things are produced. He posits, for example, “What if the throttle body is a gasket?” He explains that one of the biggest concerns associated with throttle bodies is dimensional stability, “so why not minimize the amount of material; go to a 2D design, which gets you away from problems associated with geometry and dimensional stability.” Because there would be very little to the part, it would be economical to make it out of a more expensive polymer.

Same As It Never Was.

As Schuchardt looks to how parts are designed and made, he suggests, “When you need to separate components, make sure that they make sense for assembly and manufacturing concerns instead of using the traditional association of components.” (I.e., “This is how we’ve always done it.”) He continues, “The throttle body is a separate component right now because carburetors were separate components made by separate manufacturers.” But by rethinking these and other parts by the implementation of new designs facilitated by new materials can make a huge difference.

In some cases, the rethinking that’s required is smaller. Schuchardt says that transverse-mounted engines typically employ diecast aluminum torque struts with elastomeric grommets fitted at each end. What they have developed is a strut that’s made entirely out of a thermoplastic elastomer. “The strut is stiff but flexible. It’s not as flexible as rubber, but we’re using the whole length of the strut as a spring rather than the small grommets on the end,” he points out.

Back Over There.

One European automotive development that may make its way Over Here as there are increased environmental concerns is a permanent oil filter housing and cap. Schuchardt explains that although the disposable spin-on oil filter that we’re all familiar with is well developed and fairly economical to produce, there are some environmental issues related to the disposal of those filters, which are a combination of metal, plastic, rubber, and oil-soaked paper. In Europe, he says, manufacturers have been producing glass-reinforced nylon caps that are fitted over metal housings. “Now the housings are going to glass-reinforced nylon, as well.” A paper cartridge is then the thing that needs to be dealt with at oil change time. “Although the initial expense is higher,” he admits, “the total lifecycle cost is lower.”

When might it come Over Here? When there is an engine program that also has sales in markets Over There, probably.


  • Do Plastic Body Panels Have A Future?

    Remember those Saturn commercials showing shopping carts bouncing harmlessly off of plastic body panels? Good idea, right? But apparently the approach never really caught on. Now the question is: will it ever?

  • Multiple Choices for Light, High-Performance Chassis

    How carbon fiber is utilized is as different as the vehicles on which it is used. From full carbon tubs to partial panels to welded steel tube sandwich structures, the only limitation is imagination.

  • BMW & CFRP

    A look at the 7 Series Carbon Core.